Rusty Nail -- Variation #2

Some folks look sideways at the Rusty Nail, and I get it; made with the wrong components, it can be a bit blunt. My approach favors balance over brute force, which is why I build this drink with these specific bottles. We start with Monkey Shoulder, a blended malt Scotch that brings a creamy, malty character without any aggressive smoke, creating a perfect foundation for a home bar stocked with versatile craft spirits. Then comes the Drambuie, providing its signature honeyed sweetness and a subtle herbal complexity that hooks right into the whisky. These are the exact cocktail ingredients I use because they create a better, more nuanced version of the classic two-bottle cocktail. As Anders Erickson, I've curated this collection for the House of Bitter Bear spirits to make building great drinks straightforward. A bright zip from a lemon peel over the top cuts through the richness, and you're left with a truly satisfying sipper.

Approximate ABV 35.0%
Approximate Price / Cocktail $5.32
Taste Foundation Sweet
Taste Nuance Spicy, Herbal, Fruity

Recipe Ingredients

Recipe Directions

1. Combine Scotch and Drambuie in a mixing glass.
2. Add ice. Stir until thoroughly chilled.
3. Strain into a rocks glass over fresh ice.
4. Express the oils from a lemon zest over the drink, then drop it in.

Shop the Ingredients

Need more inspiration?

Try our Shop by Recipe feature! Browse and watch Anders Erickson cocktail videos and find the spirits you need to make them at home.

Shop by Recipe